The right to ignorance and autonomy (in Polish)

Main Article Content

Olga Dryla

Abstract

The article explores the problem of whether a person as an autonomous individual has the right not to know about the state of their health. The point of reference is the classic article by John Harris and Kirsty Keywood, “Ignorance, Information and Autonomy”, in which they claim that the alleged right to ignorance is incompatible with autonomy. The author undertakes a critical analysis of the concept of autonomy adopted by these authors, which leads them to conclude (1) that such autonomy cannot be regarded as the supreme value of medical ethics, and (2) that it excludes attempts undertaken by its proponents to ground the right to ignorance in other values. The author argues that a properly formulated the concept of autonomy allows one to conclude that the patient, as an autonomous individual has the right not to know about their health.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Dryla, Olga. 2012. “The Right to Ignorance and Autonomy (in Polish)”. Diametros, no. 32 (June):19-36. https://doi.org/10.13153/diam.32.2012.475.
Section
Special topic – Bioethics and genetics
Author Biography

Olga Dryla, Jagiellonian University

Olga Dryla, PhD Institute of Philosophy Jagiellonian University olga.dryla@uj.edu.pl
Share |

References

Beauchamp, Childress [1996] – Tom L. Beauchamp, James F. Childress, Zasady etyki medycznej, tłum. W. Jałcórzyński, Książka i Wiedza, Warszawa 1996.
View in Google Scholar

Harris, Keywood [2001] – J. Harris, K. Keywood, Ignorance, Information and Autonomy, “Theoretical Medicine” (22) 2001, s. 415-436.
View in Google Scholar

Laurie [1999] – G.T. Laurie, In Defence of Ignorance: Genetic Information and the Right not to Know, “European Journal of Health Law” 6 (1999), s. 119-132.
View in Google Scholar

Rhodes [1998] – R. Rhodes, Genetic Links, Family Ties, and Social Bonds: Rights and Responsibilities in the Face of Genetic Knowledge, “Journal of Medicine and Philosophy”, 23(1) 1998, s. 10-30.
View in Google Scholar

Rhodes [2000] – R. Rhodes, Autonomy, Respect, and Genetic Information Policy: A Reply to Tuija Takala and Matti Häyry, “Journal of Medicine and Philosophy”, 25(1) 2000, s. 114-120.
View in Google Scholar

Takala [1999] – T. Takala, The Right to Genetic Ignorance Confirmed, “Bioethics”, 13(3/4) 1999, s. 289-293.
View in Google Scholar

Takala [2001] – T. Takala, Genetic Ignorance and Reasonable Paternalism, “Theoretical Medicine” (22) 2001, s. 485-491.
View in Google Scholar

Takala, Häyry [2000] – T. Takala, M. Häyry, Genetic Ignorance, Moral Obligation and Social Duties, “Journal of Medicine and Philosophy”, 25 (1) 2000, s. 107-113.
View in Google Scholar

Wilson [2005] – J. Wilson, To Know or not to Know? Genetic Ignorance, Autonomy and Paternalism, “Bioethics” 19(5-6) 2005, s. 493-504.
View in Google Scholar