Kant on the Jews and their Religion

Main Article Content

Wojciech Kozyra
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2210-4559

Abstract

The main focus of the article is the analysis of Kant’s notion of Judaism and his attitude toward the Jewish nation in a new context. Kant’s views on the Jewish religion are juxtaposed with those of Mendelssohn and Spinoza in order to emphasize several interesting features of Kant’s political and religious thought. In particular, the analysis shows that, unlike Mendelssohn, Kant did not consider tolerance to be the last word of the enlightened state in matters of its coexistence with religion. The author also argues that Kant’s fascination with Mendelssohn’s Jerusalem was premature and that his later disappointment with Mendelssohn’s persistent adherence to Jewish orthodoxy reflects his understanding of the condition of Judaism in the context of the new era of Enlightenment. Moreover, the paper addresses in a novel way the relevant connections between Kant and Spinoza, showing substantive similarities between their notions of Judaism and Christianity, and provides an overview of Kant’s historical involvement with Jewish issues, which are significant given the argumentative structure of the article.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Kozyra, Wojciech. 2020. “Kant on the Jews and Their Religion ”. Diametros 17 (65), 32-55. https://doi.org/10.33392/diam.1540.
Section
Articles
Share |

References

Altman A. (1973), Moses Mendelssohn. A Biographical Study, The Jewish Publication Society of America, Philadelphia.
View in Google Scholar

Altman A. (1983), Introduction, [in:] M. Mendelssohn, Jerusalem, or, On the Religious Power and Judaism, trans. A. Arkush, University Press of New England, Hanover, London: 1–31.
View in Google Scholar

Ascher S. (1794), Eisenmenger der Zweite, K.L. Hartmann, Berlin.
View in Google Scholar

Arkush A. (1994), Moses Mendelssohn and the Enlightenment, State University of New York Press, Albany.
View in Google Scholar

Bendavid L. (1793), Etwas zur Charakteristik der Juden, Joseph Stabel, Leipzig.
View in Google Scholar

Bohatec J. (1966), Die Religionsphilosophie Kants in der Religion innerhalb der Grenzen der bloßen Vernunft mit besonderer Berücksichtigung ihrer theologisch-dogmatischen Quellen, Georg Olms, Hildesheim.
View in Google Scholar

Cohen H. (2009), Innere Beziehungen der Kantischen Philosophie zum Judentum, [in:] H. Cohen, Werke. vol. 15: Kleinere Schriften IV (1907–1912), H. Wiedebach (ed.), Georg Olms, Hildesheim, Zürich, New York.
View in Google Scholar

Dietzsch S. (2003), Immanuel Kant. Eine Biographie, Reclam, Leipzig.
View in Google Scholar

Eckstein W. (1944), “Rousseau and Spinoza: Their Political Theories and Their Conception of Ethical Freedom,” Journal of the History of Ideas 5 (3): 259–291.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Feiner S. (2010), Moses Mendelssohn: Sage of Modernity, trans. Anthony Berris, Yale University Press, New Heaven, London.
View in Google Scholar

Fichte J.G. (1793), Beitrag zur Berichtigung der Urteile des Publikums über die französische Revolution. Erster Teil. Zur Beurteilung ihrer Rechtmäßigkeit, Ferdinand Troschel, Danzig.
View in Google Scholar

Franks P.W. (2007), The Jewish Philosophy after Kant: The Legacy of Salomon Maimon, [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Modern Jewish Philosophy, M.L. Morgan, P. Gordon (eds.), Cambridge University Press, New York: 53–79.
View in Google Scholar

Guttman J. (1908), Kant und das Judentum, [in:] N. Porges, Joseph Bechor Schor: ein nordfranzösischer Bibelerklärer des XII Jahrhunderts, J. Guttmann, Kant und das Judentum. Zwei Vorträge gehalten in der Generalversammlung der Gesellschaft am 23. Dezember 1907 zu Berlin, Gesellschaft der Wissenschaft des Judentums (ed.), Gustav Fock, Leipzig: 40–61.
View in Google Scholar

Gottlieb M. (2011), Faith and Freedom. Moses Mendelssohn’s Theological-Political Thought, Oxford University Press, New York.
View in Google Scholar

Graupe H.M. (1961), “Kant und das Judentum,” Zeitschrift für Religions- und Geistesgeschichte 31 (4): 308–333.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Guyer P. (2020), Reason and Experience in Mendelssohn and Kant, Oxford University Press, New York.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Halbertal M. (1997), People of the Book: Cannon, Meaning, and Authority, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA, London.
View in Google Scholar

Heine H. (1997), Zur Geschichte der Religion und Philosophie in Deutschland, Reclam, Stuttgart.
View in Google Scholar

Heman F. (1901), “Kant und Spinoza,” Kant-Studien 5 (1–3): 273–339.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Hirschel M. (1788), Kampf der jüdischen Hierarchie mit der Vernunft, W.G. Korn, Breslau.
View in Google Scholar

Hunter G. (2017), Radical Protestantism in Spinoza’s Thought, Routledge, London, New York.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kaufmann W. (2009), Goethe, Kant, and Hegel: Discovering the Mind, vol. 1, Transaction, New Brunswick, London.
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1986), Briefwechsel, R. Malter, J. Kopper (eds.), Felix Meiner, Hamburg.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1987), Critique of Judgment, trans. W.S. Pluhar, Hackett, Indianapolis, Cambridge.
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1996a), Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason, trans. G. di Giovanni, [in:] I. Kant, Religion and Rational Theology, Cambridge University Press, New York: 39–217.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1996b), The Conflict of the Faculties, trans. M.J. Gregor, R. Anchor, [in:] I. Kant, Religion and Rational Theology, Cambridge University Press, New York: 223–329.
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1996c), Toward Perpetual Peace, trans. M.J. Gregor, [in:] I. Kant, Practical Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, New York: 311–353.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (1999), Correspondence, trans. A. Zweig, Cambridge University Press, New York.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (2007), Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View, trans. M. Gregor, [in:] I. Kant, Anthropology, History and Education, Cambridge University Press, New York: 227–430.
View in Google Scholar

Kant I. (2011), Remarks in the Observations on the Feeling of the Beautiful and Sublime, trans. T. Hilgers, U. Abacý, M. Nance, [in:] I. Kant, Observations on the Feeling of the Beautiful and Sublime and Other Writings, Cambridge University Press, New York: 65–205.
View in Google Scholar

Keenecke A. (2007), Isaac Abraham Euchel: Architekt der Haskala, Wallstein, Göttingen.
View in Google Scholar

Kisner M. (2011), Spinoza on Human Freedom: Reason, Autonomy and the Good Life, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
View in Google Scholar

Kozyra W. (2018), “Is Spinoza’s Ethics Heteronomous in the Kantian Sense of the Term?,” Kantian Journal 37 (4): 35–66.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Kozyra W. (2019), “Jeszajahu Lejbowic: Kant, judaizm, humanizm,” Przegląd Filozoficzny – Nowa Seria 2 (28): 115–123.
View in Google Scholar

Kupś T. (2008), Filozofia religii Immanuela Kanta, Wydawnictwo Naukowe Uniwersytetu Mikołaja Kopernika, Toruń.
View in Google Scholar

Lazarus M. (1898), Die Ethik des Judenthums, J. Kauffmann Verlag, Frankfurt am Main.
View in Google Scholar

Leibowitz Y. (1994), Gespräche über Gott und die Welt, interview by Michael Shashar, trans. M. Schmidt, Insel Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, Leipzig.
View in Google Scholar

Lessing G.E. (1959), Die Erziehung des Menschengeschlechts, [in:] G.E. Lessing, Gesammelte Werke I, W. Stammler (ed.), Carl Hanser, München: 1010–1035.
View in Google Scholar

Maimon S. (2018), The Autobiography of Solomon Maimon, trans. P. Reitter, Princeton University Press, Princeton.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Meyer M.A. (1995), Response to Modernity. A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism, Wayne State University Press, Detroit.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (1782), Vorrede, trans. M. Herz, [in:] Manasseh Ben Israel, Rettung der Juden, Friedrich Nicolai, Berlin, Stettin.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (1983), Jerusalem: Or, on the Religious Power and Judaism, trans. A. Arkush, University Press of New England, Hanover, London.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (1997), On the Question: What Does ‘To Enlighten’ Mean?, trans. D.O. Dahlstrom, [in:] M. Mendelssohn, Philosophical Writings, Cambridge University Press, New York: 311–318.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (2011a), Morning Hours. Lectures on God’s Existence, trans. D.O. Dalhstrom, C. Dyck, Springer, Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London, New York.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (2011b), Writings on Judaism, Christianity, and the Bible, M. Gottlieb (ed.), trans. C. Bowman, E. Sacks, A. Arkush, Brandeis University Press, Waltham.
View in Google Scholar

Mendelssohn M. (2012), To the Friends of Lessing, trans. Bruce Rosenstock, [in:] M. Mendelssohn, Last Works, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, Chicago, Springfield.
View in Google Scholar

Munk R. (2006), “Mendelssohn and Kant on Judaism,” Jewish Studies Quarterly 13 (3): 215–222.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Oettli S. (1906), Das Urteil Kants über die alttestamentische Religion, Hans Adler, Greifswald.
View in Google Scholar

Pines S. (1997), Spinoza’s Tractatus Theologico-Politicus, Maimonides and Kant, [in:] S. Pines, Studies in the History of Jewish Thought, W.Z. Harvey, M. Idel (eds.), The Magnes Press, Jerusalem: 660–712.
View in Google Scholar

Poliakov L. (1981), Histoire de l’antisémitisme, tome 2, l’âge de la science, Calmann-Lévy, Paris.
View in Google Scholar

Rose S.E. (2014), Off with Their Heads? Lazarus Bendavid’s Vision of Kantian Subjects at the End of Jewish History, [in:] S.E. Rose, Jewish Philosophical Politics in Germany 1789–1848, Brandeis University Press, Waltham: 14–44.
View in Google Scholar

Rosenstock B. (2010), Philosophy and the Jewish Question. Mendelssohn, Rosenzweig, and Beyond, Fordham University Press, New York.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Schmidt J. (2015), Niemieckie oświecenie, trans. A. Tomaszewska, [in:] Filozofia Oświecenia. Radykalizm, religia, kosmopolityzm, J. Miklaszewska, A. Tomaszewska (eds.), Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, Kraków: 65–95.
View in Google Scholar

Schulte Ch. (2002), Die jüdische Aufklärung: Philosophie, Religion, Geschichte, C.H. Beck, München.
View in Google Scholar

Sorkin D. (2012), Moses Mendelssohn and the Religious Enlightenment, Peter Halban, London.
View in Google Scholar

Spinoza B. (1992), Ethics, trans. S. Shirley, [in:] B. Spinoza, Ethics, Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect and Selected Letters, Hackett, Indianapolis, Cambridge: 31–223.
View in Google Scholar

Spinoza B. (2007), Theological-Political Treatise, trans. J. Israel, M. Silverthorne, Cambridge University Press, New York.
View in Google Scholar

Spinoza B. (2016), Theological-Political Treatise, trans. Edwin Curley, [in:] B. Spinoza, The Collected Works of Spinoza, Princeton University Press, Princeton, Oxford: 65–357.
View in Google Scholar

Stangneth B. (2001), Antisemitische und Antijudaistische Motive bei Immanuel Kant? Tatsachen, Meinungen, Ursachen, [in:] Antisemitismus bei Kant und anderen Denkern der Aufklärung, H. Gronke, T. Meyer, B. Neisser (eds.), Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg: 11–125.
View in Google Scholar

Strauss L. (1988), How to Study Spinoza’s Theologico-Political Treatise, [in:] L. Strauss, Persecution and the Art of Writing, The University of Chicago Press, London, Chicago: 142–203.
View in Google Scholar

Tomaszewska A. (2016a), “Kant’s Reconception of Religion and Contemporary Secularism,” Roczniki Filozoficzne 64 (4): 125–149.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Tomaszewska A. (2016b), W stronę radykalnego Oświecenia: uwagi o religii według Spinozy i Kanta, [in:] Znaczenie filozofii Oświecenia, B. Grabowska, A. Grzeliński, J. Żelazna (eds.), Wydawnictwo Naukowe Uniwersytetu Mikołaja Kopernika, Toruń: 167–187.
View in Google Scholar

Tomaszewska A. (2020), “Filozofia religii Kanta w kontekście nowożytnego racjonalizmu religijnego,” Studia z Historii Filozofii 1 (11): 123–147.


DOI
View in Google Scholar

Walther M. (2008), Konsistenz der Maximen: Universalisierbarkeit und Moralität nach Spinoza und Kant, [in:] Motivationen für das Selbst. Kant und Spinoza im Vergleich, A. Tillkorn (ed.), Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden: 109–132.
View in Google Scholar

Wodziński M. (2003), Oświecenie żydowskie w Królestwie Polskim wobec chasydyzmu, Wydawnictwo Cyklady, Warszawa.
View in Google Scholar

Zweig A. (1999), Introduction, [in:] I. Kant, Correspondence, trans. A. Zweig, Cambridge University Press, New York: 1–42.
View in Google Scholar