Models, Metaphors, and Economic Theory (in Polish)

Main Article Content

Łukasz Hardt

Abstract

The paper conceptualizes economic models as metaphors. It presents two different approaches to economic modeling. In the first one, economic models are treated as isolations which aim at representing the real world. In the second, they are conceptualized according to various philosophical approaches that are close to fictionalism. The aim of such modeling is to persuade and not to represent. Next, the author tries to escape the dichotomy between models as isolations and models as purely rhetorical devices by referring to N. Cartwright’s understanding of economic models. The issue of their realism is also considered. The final conclusion states that models (in economics) are very similar to metaphors.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Hardt, Łukasz. 2014. “Models, Metaphors, and Economic Theory (in Polish)”. Diametros, no. 41 (September):13-37. https://doi.org/10.13153/diam.41.2014.650.
Section
Articles
Author Biography

Łukasz Hardt, University of Warsaw

Łukasz Hardt, Ph.D.University of WarsawFaculty of Economic SciencesDługa St. 44/5000-241 Warsaw, Polande-mail: lhardt@wne.uw.edu.pl
Share |

References

Arystoteles [1988a] – Arystoteles, Retoryka, PWN, Warszawa 1988.
View in Google Scholar

Arystoteles [1988b] – Arystoteles, Poetyka, PWN, Warszawa 1988.
View in Google Scholar

Bartkowiak [2012] – K. Bartkowiak, Davidson i Rorty o metaforze, „Przegląd Filozoficzny – Nowa Seria”, 81 (1) 2012, s. 221-236.
View in Google Scholar

Black [1962] – M. Black, Models and Metaphors, Cornell University Press, Ithaca 1962.
View in Google Scholar

Black [1979] – M. Black, More about Metaphors, [w:] A. Ortony (red.), Metaphor and Though, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1979, s. 19-43.
View in Google Scholar

Blaug [1995] – M. Blaug, Metodologia ekonomii, PWN, Warszawa 1995.
View in Google Scholar

Boltzmann [1902/1974] – L. Boltzmann, On the Principles of Mechanics, [w:] B. McGuinness (red.), Theoretical Physics and Philosophical Problems, Reidel, Dordrecht 1974, s. 129-152.
View in Google Scholar

Boumans [2004] – M. Boumans, Models in Economics, [w:] B. Davis, A. Marciano, J. Runde (red.), The Elgar Companion to Economics and Philosophy, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham 2004, s. 260-282.
View in Google Scholar

Boumans i in. [2010] – M. Boumans, J.B. Davis, Economic Methodology. Understanding Economics as a Science, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke 2010.
View in Google Scholar

Cartwright [1983] – N. Cartwright, How the Laws of Physics Lie, Oxford University Press, New York 1983.
View in Google Scholar

Cartwright [1989] – N. Cartwright, Nature's Capacities and their Measurement, Oxford University Press, New York 1989.
View in Google Scholar

Cartwright [1999] – N. Cartwright N., The Dappled World: A Study of the Boundaries of Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1999.
View in Google Scholar

Cartwright i in. [1995] – N. Cartwright, T. Shomar, M. Suarez, The Tool-box of Science, [w:] W.E. Herfel i in. (red.), Theories and Models in Scientific Processes, Rodopi B.V., Amsterdam-Atlanta 1995, s. 137-149.
View in Google Scholar

Crespo [2008] – R. Crespo, Nancy Cartwright and Aristotle, „Working Paper Series Austral University”, (2) 2008.
View in Google Scholar

Fisher [1892/1925] – I. Fisher, Mathematical Investigations in the Theory of Value and Prices, Yale University Press, New Heaven 1925.
View in Google Scholar

Fisher [1939] – I. Fisher, A Three-dimensional Representation of the Factors of Production and their Remuneration, Marginally and Residually, „Econometrica” 7 (4) 1939, s. 304-311.
View in Google Scholar

Friedman [1953] – M. Friedman, The Methodology of Positive Economics, [w:] M. Friedman, Essays in Positive Economics, Chicago University Press, Chicago 1953, s. 3-43.
View in Google Scholar

Frege [1892/1970] – G. Frege, On Sense and Reference, [w:] P. Geach, M. Black (red.), Translations from the Philosophical Writings of G. Frege, Basil Blackwell, Oxford 1970, s. 56-78.
View in Google Scholar

Frigg [2006] – R. Frigg, Scientific Models, [w:] S. Sarkar, J. Pfeifer (red.), The Philosophy of Science: An Encyclopedia, Routledge, New York 2006, s. 740-749.
View in Google Scholar

Frigg i in. [2012] – R. Frigg, S. Hartmann, Models in Science, [w:] E.N. Zalta (red.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2006/entries/models-science/ [data dostępu: 8/3/2013].
View in Google Scholar

Guala [2005] – F. Guala, The Methodology of Experimental Economic, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2005.
View in Google Scholar

Grüne-Yanoff [2009] – T. Grüne-Yanoff, Preface to ‘Economic Models as Credible Worlds or as Isolating Tools, „Erkenntnis” 70 (1) 2009, s. 1-2.
View in Google Scholar

Hardt [2012] – Ł. Hardt, Problem realistyczności założeń w teorii ekonomii, „Ekonomista”, (1) 2012, s. 21-40.
View in Google Scholar

Hardt [2013] – Ł. Hardt, Studia z realistycznej filozofii ekonomii, C.H. Beck, Warszawa 2013.
View in Google Scholar

Hutchison [1938] – T. Hutchison, The Significance and Basic Postulates of Economic Theory, Macmillan, London 1938.
View in Google Scholar

Keynes [1985] – J.M. Keynes, Ogólna teoria zatrudnienia, procentu i pieniądza, PWN, Warszawa 1985.
View in Google Scholar

Klein [1970] – M.J. Klein, Paul Ehrenfest. The Making of a Theoretical Physicist, vol. 1., North-Holland, Amsterdam 1970.
View in Google Scholar

Knuuttila [2009] – T. Knuuttila, Isolating Representations vs. Credible Constructions? Economic Modelling in Theory and Practice, „Erkenntnis” 70 (1) 2009, s. 59-80.
View in Google Scholar

Lagueux [1999] – M. Lagueux, Do Metaphors Affect Economic Theory?, „Economics and Philosophy”, 15 (1) 1999, s. 1-22.
View in Google Scholar

Lawson [1997] – T. Lawson, Economics & Reality, Routledge, Abingdon 1997.
View in Google Scholar

Lawson [2003] – T. Lawson, Reorienting Economics, Routledge, Abingdon 2003.
View in Google Scholar

Lazear [2000] – E. Lazear, Economic Imperialism, „Quarterly Journal of Economics” 115 (1) 2000, s. 99-146.
View in Google Scholar

Lucas [1980] – R. Lucas, Methods and Problems in Business Cycle Theory, „Journal of Money, Credit and Banking”, 12 (4) 1980, s. 696-715.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [1992] – U. Mäki, On the Method of Isolation in Economics, [w:] C. Dilworth (red.), Idealization IV: Intelligibility in Science, „Special Issue of Poznan Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities”, s. 319-354.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [1995] – U. Mäki, Diagnosing McCloskey, „Journal of Economic Literature”, 33 (3) 1995, s. 1300-1318.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [2001] – U. Mäki, The Way the World Works (www): Towards an Ontology of Theory Choice, [w:] U. Mäki (red.), The Economic World View. Studies in the Ontology of Economics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2001, s. 369-389.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [2005] – U. Mäki, Models are Experiments, Experiments are Models, „Journal of Economic Methodology”, 12 (2) 2005, s. 303-315.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [2009a] – U. Mäki, MISSing the World. Models as Isolations and Credible Surrogate Systems, „Erkenntnis”, 70 (1) 2009, s. 29-43.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [2009b] – U. Mäki, Realistic Realism about Unrealistic Models, [w:] H. Kincaid, D. Ross (red.), The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Economics, Oxford University Press US, New York 2009, s. 68-98.
View in Google Scholar

Mäki [2011] – U. Mäki, Models and the Locus of their Truth, „Synthese”, 180 (1) 2011, s. 47-63.
View in Google Scholar

Marshall [1920] – A. Marshall, Principles of Economics, MacMillan, London 1920.
View in Google Scholar

Maxwell [1855/1965] – J.C. Maxwell, On Faraday’s Lines of Force, [w:] W.D. Niven (red.), The Scientific Papers of J.C. Maxwell, vol. 1., Dover, New York 1965, s. 155-229.
View in Google Scholar

McCloskey [1990] – D. McCloskey, Storytelling in Economics, [w:] D.C. Lavoie (red.), Economics and Hermeneutics, Routledge&Kegan Paul, London 1990, s. 5-22.
View in Google Scholar

McCloskey [1983] – D. McCloskey, The Rhetoric of Economics, „Journal of Economic Literature” 21 (2) 1983, s. 481-517.
View in Google Scholar

McCloskey [1984] – D. McCloskey, The Literary Character of Economics, „Daedalus” 113 (3) 1984, s. 97-119.
View in Google Scholar

McCloskey [1985] – D. McCloskey, The Rhetoric of Economics, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison 1985.
View in Google Scholar

Mirowski [2002] – P. Mirowski, Machine Dreams: Economics Becomes a Cyborg Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2002.
View in Google Scholar

Morgan [1998] – M. Morgan, Models, [w:] J.B. Davis, D.W. Hands, U. Mäki (red.), The Handbook of Economic Methodology, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham 1998, s. 316-321.
View in Google Scholar

Morgan [2012] – M. Morgan, The World in the Model: How Economists Work and Think, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012.
View in Google Scholar

Morrison [1998] – M. Morrison, Modelling Nature: Between Physics and the Physical World, „Philosophia Naturalis”, (35) 1998, s. 65-85.
View in Google Scholar

Nowak [1980] – L. Nowak, The Structure of Idealization. Towards a Systematic Interpretation of the Marxian Idea of Science, Reidel, Dordrecht 1980.
View in Google Scholar

Reiss [2013] – J. Reiss, Philosophy of Economics. A Contemporary Introduction, Routledge, London 2013.
View in Google Scholar

Ricœur [1986] – P. Ricœur, The Rule of Metaphor, Routledge&Kegan Paul, London 1986.
View in Google Scholar

Russell [1903] – B. Russell, The Study of Mathematics, Allen and Unwin, Cambridge 1903.
View in Google Scholar

Solow [1982] – R. Solow, The Economics Major: What It Is and What It Should Be: Panel Discussion, „American Economic Review”, 72 (2) 1982, s. 139.
View in Google Scholar

Suppes [2002] – P. Suppes, Representation and Invariance of Scientific Structures, CSLI Publications, Stanford CA 2002. [data dostępu: 8/3/2013]
View in Google Scholar

Wickens [2012] – M. Wickens, How Useful are DSGE Macroeconomic Models for Forecasting?, Prepared for Konstanz Seminar, May 2012, http://www.iiw.uni-bonn.de/konstanz/2012/Paper_Wickens.pdf [data dostępu: 8/3/2013].
View in Google Scholar

Wieland V., Cwik T., Müller G.J. (2012), A New Comparative Approach to Macroeconomic Modeling and Policy Analysis, opracowanie niepublikowane, http://www.voxeu.org/sites/default/files/file/Wielandetal_120123.pdf [data dostępu: 8/3/2013].
View in Google Scholar

Van Fraassen [1980] – B. Van Fraassen, The Scientific Image, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1980.
View in Google Scholar

Zeidler [2011] – P. Zeidler, Prawda i znaczenie w świetle metaforycznego charakteru aparatu konceptualnego nauk empirycznych, w: D. Leszczyński (red.), Prawda, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocławskiego, Wrocław 2011, s. 325-343.
View in Google Scholar