Clinical Ethics Committees and Pediatrics. An Evaluation of Case Consultations
Main Article Content
Abstract
Since Clinical Ethics Consultation has become important in the public health sector in the last decade in Germany, there are on-going questions about effectiveness. Targets have been established by the Ethics Committees, in regard to assisting patients, families and health care teams at times of ethical conflicts during the decision-making process in medical care.
Of all the ethics consultations over the last eight years at Erlangen University Hospital the consultations carried out in the pediatric department were chosen to be reviewed by a pediatrician and an ethicist. These were evaluated on the basis of team formation, interdisciplinary orientation, ethical criteria, completeness and methods of documentation.
Results of the analysis of those records show a well-organized consultation team with regard to its personnel composition. Discrepancies with ethical questions posed in the literature are revealed, and also some partially incomplete documentation regarding medical facts and descriptions of the patients' or parents' opinion.
Article Details
By submitting his/her work to the Editorial Board, the author accepts, upon having his/her text recommended for publication, that Diametros applies the Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license to the works we publish. Under this license, authors agree to make articles legally available for reuse, without permission or fees. Anyone may read, download, copy, print, distribute or reuse these articles without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author, as long as the author and original source are properly cited. The author holds the copyright without any other restrictions. Full information about CC-BY: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.
How to Cite
References
Agich [2003] – G. J. Agich, Joining the Team: Ethics Consultation at the Cleveland Clinic, “HEC Forum” 15 (4) 2003, pp. 310-322.
Bramstedt et al. [2009] – K. A. Bramstedt, A. R. Jonsen, W. S. Andereck, J. W. McGaughey, A. B. Neidich, Optimising the documentation practices of an Ethics Consultation Service. “Journal of Medical Ethics” 35, 2009, pp. 47-50.
Dobrin [2003] – A. Dobrin, Moral reasoning of members of hospital ethics committees: a pilot study, “The Journal of Clinical Ethics” 14, 2003, pp. 270-275.
Dörries [2003] – A. Dörries, Mixed Feelings: Physicians’ Concerns about clinical ethics committees in Germany, “HEC Forum” 15 (3), 2003, pp. 245-257.
Dörries [2007] – A. Dörries, K. Hespe-Jungesblut, Die Implementierung Klinischer Ethikberatung in Deutschland. Ergebnisse einer bundesweiten Umfrage bei Krankenhäusern, “Ethik in der Medizin” 19, 2007, pp. 148-156.
Dörries et al. [2008] – A. Dörries, G. Neitzke, A. Simon, J. Vollmann (Ed.), Klinische Ethikberatung. Ein Praxisbuch, Stuttgart 2008.
Edens et al. [1990] – M. J. Edens, F. D. Eyler, J. T. Wagner, D. V. Eitzman, Neonatal ethics: Development of a Consultative Group, “Paediatrics” 86 (6), 1990, pp. 944-949.
Fox et al. [2007] – E. Fox, S. Myers, R. A. Pearlman, Ethics consultation in United States: a national survey, “American Journal of Bioethics” 7, 2007, pp. 13-25.
Frewer [2000] – A. Frewer, Medizin und Moral in Weimarer Republik und Nationalsozialismus. Die Zeitschrift „Ethik“ unter Emil Abderhalden, Campus Verlag, Frankfurt a.M., New York 2000.
Frewer [2008] – A. Frewer, Ethikkomitees zur Beratung in der Medizin. Entwicklung und Probleme der Institutionalisierung, “Jahrbuch Ethik in der Klinik” 1, 2008, pp. 47-74.
Frewer, Fahr [2007] – A. Frewer, U. Fahr, Clinical Ethics and Confidentiality. Opinions of Experts and Ethics Committees, “HEC Forum” 19 (4), 2007, pp. 275-289.
Frewer et al. [2008] – A. Frewer, U. Fahr, W. Rascher (Eds.), Klinische Ethikkomitees. Chan- cen, Risiken und Nebenwirkungen, “Jahrbuch Ethik in der Klinik (JEK)”, Band 1, Kö- nigshausen & Neumann, Würzburg 2008.
Griener, Storch [1992] – G. G. Griener, J. L. Storch, Hospital Ethics Committees: Problems in Evaluation, “HEC Forum” 4 (1), 1992, pp. 5-18.
Guo, Schick [2003] – L. Guo, I. C. Schick, The Impact of Committee characteristics on the success of healthcare ethics committees, “HEC Forum” 15 (3) 2003, pp. 287-299.
Hoffmann [1993] – D. Hoffmann, Evaluating ethics committees: A view from the outside, “The Milbank Quarterly” 71, 1993, pp. 677-701.
Kliegman et al. [1986] – R. M. Kliegman, M. B. Mahowald, S. J. Youngner, In our best interests: Experience and workings of an ethics review committee, “Journal of Paediatrics” 108 (2), 1986, pp. 178-188.
Kobert et al. [2008] – K. Kobert, M. Pfäfflin, S. Reiter-Theil, Der klinische Ethik- Beratungsdienst im Evangelischen Krankenhaus Bielefeld. Hintergrund, Konzepte und Stra- tegien zur Evaluation, “Ethik in der Medizin” 20, 2008, pp. 122-133.
Larcher et al. [1997] – V. F. Larcher, B. Lask, J. M. McCarthy, Paediatrics at the cutting edge: do we need clinical ethics committees?, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 23, 1997, pp. 245- 249.
Michaels, Oliver [1986] – R. H. Michaels, T. K. Oliver, Human Rights Consultation: A 12 Year Experience of a Pediatric Bioethics Committee, “Paediatrics” 78 (4), 1986, pp. 566-572.
Neitzke [2003] – G. Neitzke, Ethikberatung in der Pädiatrie. In: C. Wiesemann, A. Dörries, G. Wolfslast, & A. Simon (Eds.), Das Kind als Patient. Ethische Konflikte zwischen Kindes- wohl und Kindeswille. Kultur der Medizin, Bd. 7. Campus, Frankfurt, pp. 174-193.
Orr, Moon [1993] – R. D. Orr, E. Moon, Effectiveness of an ethics consultation service, “Journal of Family Practice” 36, 1993, pp. 49-53.
Orr, Perkin [1994] – R. D. Orr, R. M. Perkin, Clinical Ethics Consultation with Children, “Journals of Clinical Ethics” 5, 1994, pp. 323-328.
Orr et al. [1996] – R. D. Orr, K. R. Morton, D. M. deLeon, J. C. Fals, Evaluation of an ethics consultation service: patient and family perspective, “The American Journal of Medicine” 101, 1996, pp. 135-141.
Orr, Shelton [2009] – R. D. Orr, W. Shelton, A Process and Format for Clinical Ethics Consulta- tion, “Journal of Clinical Ethics” 20, 2009, pp. 79-89.
Reichwald-Klugger et al. [2000] – E. Reichwald-Klugger, J. Rosenkranz, O. Mehls, Terminale Niereninsuffizienz und geistige Behinderung Pilotstudie zu den Behandlungserfahrun- gen kindernephrologischer Zentren, “Monatsschrift Kinderheilkunde” 148, Nr. 6, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg 2000, pp. 611-615.
Salathé et al. [2008] – M. Salathé, H. Amstad, M. Jünger, M. Leuthold, C. Regamey, Institutionalisierung der Ethikberatung an Akutspitälern, psychiatrischen Kliniken, Pflegeheimen und Einrichtungen der Rehabilitation in der Schweiz: Zweite Umfrage der Schweizerischen Akademie der Medizinischen Wissenschaften, “Bioethica Forum” Vol. 1 Nr. 1, 2008, pp. 8-14.
Schneiderman et al. [2000] – L. J. Schneiderman, T. Gilmer, H. D. Teetzel, Impact of ethics consultations in the intensive care setting: a randomized, controlled trial, “Critical Care Medicine” 28, 2000, pp. 3920-3924.
Schneiderman et al. [2003] – L. J. Schneiderman, T. Gilmer, H. D. Teetzel, D. O. Dugan, J. Blustein, R. Cranford, K. B. Briggs, G. I. Komatsu, P. Goodman-Crews, F. Cohn, E.
W. D. Young, Effect of ethics consultations on nonbeneficial life-sustaining treatments in the intensive care setting: a randomized controlled trial, “Journal of the American Medical Association” 290, 2003, pp. 1166-1172.
Simon [2008] – A. Simon, Qualitätssicherung und Evaluation von Ethikberatung. In: A. Dörries, G. Neitzke, A. Simon, J. Vollmann (Eds.), Klinische Ethikberatung. Ein Praxisbuch, Kohlhammer, Stuttgart 2008, pp. 58-75.
Slowther, Hope [2000] – A. Slowther, T. Hope, Clinical ethics committees: They can change clinical practice but need evaluation, “British Medical Journal” 321, 2000, pp. 649-650.
Steinkamp, Gordijn [2001] – N. Steinkamp, B. Gordijn, HECs in Germany: Clinical Ethics Consultation in Development, “HEC Forum” 13 (3), 2001, pp. 215-224.
Tulsky, Fox [1996] – J. A. Tulsky, E. Fox, Evaluation ethics consultation: Framing the questions, “Journal of Clinical Ethics” 7, 1996, pp. 109-115.
Vollmann [2008] – J. Vollmann, Klinische Ethikkomitees und Ethikberatung in Deutschland: Bisherige Entwicklung und zukünftige Perspektiven, “Bioethica Forum” Vol. 1, Nr. 1, 2008, pp. 33-39.
Vollmann et al. [2004] – J. Vollmann, N. Burchardi, A. Weidtmann, Klinische Ethikkomitees an deutschen Universitätskliniken. Eine Befragung aller Ärztlichen Direktoren und Pflegedirektoren, “Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift” 129, 2004, pp. 1227-1243.
Vollmann, Weidtmann [2003] – J. Vollmann, A. Weidtmann, Das klinische Ethikkomitee des Erlanger Universitätsklinikums. Institutionalisierung, Arbeitsweise, Perspektiven, “Ethik in der Medizin” 15, 2003, pp. 229-238.
Wernstedt, Vollmann [2005] – T. Wernstedt, J. Vollmann, Das Erlanger klinische Ethikkomitee. Organisationsethik an einem deutschen Universitätsklinikum, “Ethik in der Medizin” 17, 2005, pp. 44-51.
Williamson et al. [2007] – L. Williamson, S. McLean, J. Connel, Clinical Ethics Committees in the United Kingdom Towards evaluation, “Medical Law International” 8(3), 2007, pp. 221-238.
Zentrale Ethikkommission [2006] – Zentrale Ethikkommission, Ethikberatung in der Medizin. Stellungnahme der Zentralen Kommission zur Wahrung ethischer Grundsätze in der Medizin und ihren Grenzgebieten (Zentrale Ethikkommission) bei der Bundesärztekammer zur Ethikberatung in der klinischen Medizin, “Deutsches Ärzteblatt” 103 (24), 2006, pp. 1703-1707.