Hospital Clinical Ethics Committees. The Geneva Experience - Switzerland

Main Article Content

Jean-Claude Chevrolet
Bara Ricou


Hospital ethics committees were created in the United States of America in the 1970s. Their aims were the education of the hospital personnel in the field of ethics, the development of policies and the publication of guidelines concerning ethical issues, as well as consultations and case reviews of hospitalized patients when an ethical concern was present. During the last thirty years, these committees disseminated, particularly in Western Europe. In this manuscript, we describe the benefit, but also some difficulties with these committees, and we propose some solutions. The characteristics of these committees are discussed (i.e. typology of members, functioning and legitimacy). Finally, we carefully describe our local hospital clinical ethics committee in Geneva (Switzerland), which was founded in 1994 and it still very active. After fifteen years of experience, we remain strongly in favour of the implementation of such committees in any modern hospital.


Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Chevrolet, Jean-Claude, and Bara Ricou. 2009. “Hospital Clinical Ethics Committees. The Geneva Experience - Switzerland”. Diametros, no. 22 (December):21-38.
Special topic - Clinical Ethics Committees
Author Biographies

Jean-Claude Chevrolet

Jean-Claude Chevrolet, MD Intensive Care Service University Hospital Geneva - Switzerland

Bara Ricou

Bara Ricou, MD Intensive Care Service University Hospital Geneva - Switzerland
Share |


AAP – American Academy of Pediatrics: Committee on Bioethics. Institutional ethics commit- tee, “Pediatrics” 107, 2001: 205-209.

Ackerman [1989] – T. Ackerman, Conceptualizing the role of the ethics consultant - some theo- retical issues, in: J. Fletcher, N. Quist, A. Jonsen (ed.). Ethics consultation in health care, Ann Harbor (Michigan): Health Administration Press., 1989: 37-52.

Agich [1991] – G. Agich, The question of methods in ethics consultation, “American Journal of Bioethics” 1, 2001: 31-41.

Annas [1991] – G. Annas, Ethics committees: from ethical comfort to ethical cover, “Hastings Center Report” 21, 1991: 18-21.

Aulisio et al. [2000] – M.P. Aulisio, R.M. Arnold, S.J. Youngner, Health care ethics consulta- tion: nature, goals, and competencies. A position paper from the Society for Health and Human Values-Society for Bioethics Consultation Task Force on Standards for Bioethics Consultation, “Annals of Internal Medicine” 133 (1), 2000: 59-69.

Azoulay et al. [2001] – E. Azoulay, F. Pochard, S. Chevret, Meeting the needs of ICU patients' families: a multicenter study, “American Journal of Respiratory Critical Care Medi- cine” 101, 2001: 135-139.

Barnard [1992] – D. Barnard, Reflections of a reluctant clinical ethicist: ethics consultation and the collapse of critical distance, “Theor Med” 13, 1992: 15-22.

Bartels [1988] – D. Bartels, Ethics committees and critical care: allies or adversaries?, “Perspect.

Crit. Care” 1, 1988: 83-90.

Casarett et al. [1998] – D. Casarett, F. Daskal, J. Lantos, The authority of the clinical ethicist, “Hastings Center Report” 28, 1998: 6-11.

Chevrolet [1998] – J. Chevrolet, Genève. CdECdlHUd., Atitude face à un patient en état végétatif persistant, “Médecine Hygiène” 2222, 1998: 1729-1735.

Chevrolet [1995] – J. Chevrolet, Genève. CdECdlHUd., Transplantation hépatique à partir d'un donneur vivant apparenté: une réflexion éthique, “Médecine Hygiène” 54, 1995: 2089-2092.

Chevrolet, Jolliet [1991] – J. Chevrolet, P. Jolliet, An ethical look at intensive care for patients with malignancies, “European Journal of Cancer” 27, 1991: 210-212.

Chevrolet [1993] – J. Chevrolet, Décisions éthiques et responsabilité médicale, “Médecine Hy- giène” 51, 1993: 2453-2460.

Chevrolet [2002] – J. Chevrolet, Les comités locaux d'éthique clinique hospitaliers, “Médecine Hygiène” 2407, 2002: 1781-1786.

Chevrolet [1994] – J. Chevrolet, Quelques réflexion d'un clinicien sur l'euthanasie et le droit pénal, “Médecine Hygiène” 52, 1994: 2280-2281.

Dowdy et al. [1998] – M. Dowdy, C. Robertson, J. Bander, A study of proactive ethics consultation for critically ill patients with extended length of stay, “Critical Care Medicine” 26, 1998: 252-259.

Doyal [2001] – L. Doyal, Clinical ethics committees and the formulation of health care policy, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 27, 2001 (suppl. 1): i44-i49.

DuVal [1997] – G. DuVal, Liability of ethics consultants - a case analysis, “Cambridge Quar- terly of Healthcare Ethics” 6, 1997: 269-281.

Fleetwood, Unger [1994] – J. Fleetwood, S. Unger, Institutional ethics committees and the shield of immunity, “Annals of Internal Medicine” 120, 1994: 320-325.

Fletcher, Hoffmann [1994] – J. Fletcher, D. Hoffmann, Ethics committees: time to experiment with standards, “Annals of Internal Medicine” 120, 1994: 335-338.

Fox, Tulsky [1996] – E. Fox, J. Tulsky, Evaluation research and the future of ethics consultation, “Journal of Clinical Ethics” 7, 1996: 146-149.

Frader [1992] – J. Frader, Political and interpersonal aspects of ethics consultation, “Theor Med” 13, 1992: 31-44.

Fry-Revere [1993] – S. Fry-Revere, Some suggestions for holding bioethics committees and con- sultants accountable, “Cambridge Quarterly Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 449-455.

Guerrier [2006] – M. Guerrier, Hospital based ethics, current situation in France: between "Espaces" and committees, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 32, 2006: 503-506.

Heilicser [2000] – B. Heilicser, D. Meltzer, M. Siegler, The effect of clinical ethics consultations on healthcare costs, “Journal of Clinical Ethics” 11, 2000: 31-38.

Hurst et al. [2006] – S. Hurst, J. Chevrolet, F. Loew, Methods in clinical ethics: a time for eclectic pragmatism?, “Journal of Clinical Ethics” 1, 2006: 159-164.

Hurst et al. [2005] – S. Hurst, S. Hull, G. DuVal, M. Danis, How physicians face ethical diffi- culties: a qualitative analysis, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 31, 2005: 7-14.

Hurst et al. [2007a] – S. Hurst, A. Perrier, R. Pegoraro, S. Reiter-Theil, R. Forde, A. Slowther, et al., Ethical difficulties in clinical practice: experiences of European doctors, “Jour- nal of Medical Ethics” 33, 2007: 51-57.

Hurst et al. [2007b] – S. Hurst, S. Reiter-Theil, A. Perrier, R. Forde, A. Slowther, R. Pegoraro, et al., Physicians’ access to ethics support services in four European countries, “Health Care Anal” 15, 2007: 321-335.

Hurst [2006] – S. Hurst, La consultation d'éthique: à quoi ça peut servir?, “Rev Méd Suisse” 2, 2006: 2195-2199.

Kelly, Hoyt [1996] – D. Kelly, J. Hoyt, Ethics consultation, “Critical Care Clinics” 12, 1996: 49-70.

LaPuma, Schiedermayer [1991] – J. LaPuma, D. Schiedermayer, Ethics consultation - skills, roles, and training, “Annals of Internal Medicine” 114, 1991: 155-160.

Lebeer [2005] – G. Lebeer, Clinical ethics support services in Europe, “Medicinska Etika & Bioetika/Medical Ethics & Bioethics” 11, 2005 (suppl.): 8-11.

Leeman et al. [1997] – C. Leeman, J. Fletcher, E. Spencer, S. Fry-Revere, Quality control for hospitals’ clinical ethics services: proposed standards, “Cambridge Quarterly of Health- care Ethics” 6, 1997: 257-268.

Lilje [1993] – C. Lilje, Ethics consultation: a dangerous, antidemocratic charlatanry?, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 438-442.

Lo, Schroeder [1981] – B. Lo, S. Schroeder, Frequency of ethical dilemmas in a medical inpatient service, “Archives of Internal Medicine” 141, 1981: 1062-1064.

McClung et al. [1996] – J.A. McClung, R.S. Kamer, M. DeLuca, H.J. Barber, Evaluation of a medical ethics consultation service: opinions of patients and health care providers, “American Journal of Medicine” 100 (4), 1996: 456-60.

Meulenberg et. al. [2007] – T. Meulenberg, J. Vermylen, P. Schotsmans, The current state of clinical ethics and healthcare ethics committees in Belgium, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 31, 2007: 318-321.

Mino [2001] – J. Mino, Why are there no clinical ethicists in France?, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 10, 2001: 341-344.

Mitchell, Swartz [1990] – S. Mitchell, M. Swartz, Is there a place for a lawyer on ethics commit- tees? A view from the inside, “Hastings Center Report” 20, 1990: 32-33.

Moreno [1991] – J. Moreno, Ethics consultation as moral engagement, “Bioethics” 5, 1991: 44- 56.

Orlowski et al. [2006] – J. Orlowski, S. Hein, J. Christensen, R. Meinke, T. Sincich, Why doctors use or do not use ethics consultation, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 32, 2006: 499- 502.

Paris, Reardon [2001] – J.J. Paris, F.E. Reardon, Ethics committees in critical care, “Critical Care Clinics” 2 (1), 1986: 111-21.

Pochard [2001] – F. Pochard, E. Azoulay, S. Chevret, R. Zittoun, Toward an ethical consulta- tion in intensive care?, “Critical Care Medicine” 29, 2001: 1489-1490.

Reither-Theil [2001] – S. Reither-Theil, Ethics consultation in Germany: the present situation, “HEC Forum” 13, 2001: 265-280.

Salathé et al. [2003] – M. Salathé, M. Leuthold, M. Amstad, M. Valloton, Comités d'éthique en Suisse: un état des lieux, “Bull. Méd Suisses” 84, 2003: 2264-2267.

Schiedermayer, LaPuma [1993] – D. Schiedermayer, J. LaPuma, The ethics consultant and ethics committees, and their acronyms: IRBs, HECs, RM, QA, UM, PROs, IPCs, and HREAPs, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 469-475.

Schneiderman et al. [2000] – L.J. Schneiderman, T. Gilmer, H.D. Teetzel, Impact of ethics consultations in the intensive care setting: a randomized, controlled trial, “Critical Care Medicine” 28 (12), 2000: 3920-3924.

Scofield [1993] – G. Scofield, Ethics consultation: the least dangerous profession, “Cambridge Quarterly Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 417-448.

Self [1993] – D. Self, Is ethics consultation dangerous?, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 442-445.

Siegler, Singer [1988] – M. Siegler, P. Singer, Clinical ethics consultation - Godsend or god squad?, “American Journal of Medicine” 85, 1988: 759-760.

Siegler [1986] – M. Siegler, Ethics committees - decisions by bureaucracy, “The Hastings Center Report” 16, 1986: 22-24.

Slomk [1994] – J. Slomka, The ethics committee: providing education for itself and others, “HEC Forum” 6, 1994: 31-38.

Slowther et al. [2001] – A. Slowther, T. Hope, R. Ashcroft, Clinical ethics committees: a worldwide development, “Journal of Medical Ethics” 27, 2001 (suppl. 1): i1.

Spielman [1993] – B. Spielman, Invoking the law in ethics consultation, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 457-467.

Spike, Greenlaw [2000] – J. Spike, J. Greenlaw, Ethics consultation: high ideals or unrealistic expectations?, “Annals of International Medicine” 133 (1), 2000: 55-57.

Swenson, Miller [1992] – M. Swenson, R. Miller, Ethics case reviews in health care institution. Committees, consultants or teams?, “Archives of Internal Medicine 149, 1992: 1109- 1112.

Szeremeta et al. [2001] – M. Szeremeta, J. Dawson, D. Manning, A. Watson, M. Wright, W. Notcutt, et al., Snapshots of five ethical committees in the UK, “Journal of Medical Eth- ics” 27, 2001 (suppl. 1): i9-i17.

Tuskey, Lo [1992] – J. Tulskey, B. Lo, Ethics consultation: time to focus on patients, “American Journal of Medicine” 92, 1992: 343-345.

Warnock [1991] – M. Warnock, Ethics committees, “Baillières Clin Obstet Gynecol” 5, 1991: 761-777.

Weeks, Nelson [1993] – W. Weeks, W. Nelson, The ethical role of the consultant, “Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics” 2, 1993: 477-483.