Is God Morally Indifferent? The Problem of Inference according to David Hume
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
The article is devoted to an analysis of David Hume’s position on God’s benevolence in his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. The focal point is the problem of inference and the accompanying arguments concerning the relations between good and evil, as well as the four circumstances in which evil enters the world. In the conclusion, I discuss the hypothesis of moral indifference as Hume’s skeptical voice in the debate on the possibility of inferring the moral attributes of God on the basis of experience.
Downloads
Article Details
By submitting his/her work to the Editorial Board, the author accepts, upon having his/her text recommended for publication, that Diametros applies the Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license to the works we publish. Under this license, authors agree to make articles legally available for reuse, without permission or fees. Anyone may read, download, copy, print, distribute or reuse these articles without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author, as long as the author and original source are properly cited. The author holds the copyright without any other restrictions. Full information about CC-BY: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.
References
Andre S. (1993), Was Hume an Atheist?, „Hume Studies” 1 (19): 141–166.
Butler J. (2011), The Analogy of Religion, Natural and Revealed to the Constitution and Course of Nature to Which are Added, Two Brief Dissertations, Kindle Edition.
Davis J.W. (1987), Going Out the Window: A Comment on Tweyman, „Hume Studies” 1 (13): 86–97.
Dye J. (1992), Demea’s Departure, „Hume Studies” 18 (2): 467–482.
Gale R.M. (1993), On the Nature and the Existence of God, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Gaskin J.C.A. (1988), Hume’s Philosophy of Religion, Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands.
Grzeliński A. (2009), Kategoria zła w empiryzmie Davida Hume’a, [w:] Koncepcje i problemy filozofii zła, R. Wiśniewski i M. Jaranowski (red.), Wydawnictwo Naukowe UMK, Toruń: 13–33.
Hochfeldowa A. (1962), Dawida Hume’a „Dialogi o religii naturalnej”, [w:] D. Hume, Dialogi o religii naturalnej. Naturalna historia religii wraz z dodatkami, PWN, Warszawa: VII–LIII.
Howard-Snyder D., Bergmann M., Rowe W.L. (2005), An Exchange on the Problem of Evil, [w:] God and the Problem of Evil, William L. Rowe (red.), Blackwell Publishing, Oxford: 124–158.
Hubaczek K. (2011), Bóg a zło. Problematyka teodycealna w filozofi i analitycznej, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocławskiego, Wrocław.
Hume D. (1962), Dialogi o religii naturalnej. Naturalna historia religii wraz z dodatkami, tłum. A. Hochfeldowa, PWN, Warszawa.
Hume D. (2005), Badania dotyczące rozumu ludzkiego wraz z apendyksami, tłum. D. Misztal i T. Sieczkowski, Zielona Sowa, Kraków.
Hume D. (2007), Rozdz. 7. Czwarta obiekcja, tłum. A. Grzeliński, „Nowa Krytyka” 20–21: 325–332.
Judycki S. (2009), Wszechmoc i istnienie, „Diametros” 21: 30–62.
Kraay K.J. (2003), Philo’s Argument for Divine Amorality Reconsidered, „Hume Studies” 2 (29): 283–294.
Leibniz G.W. (2001), Teodycea. O dobroci Boga, wolności człowieka i pochodzeniu zła, tłum. M. Frankiewicz, PWN, Warszawa.
Logan B. (1996), Why Hume Wasn’t an Atheist: A Reply to Andre, „Hume Studies” 22 (1): 193–202.
Malebranche N. (2003), Dialogi o metafizyce i religii. Dialogi o śmierci, tłum. P. Rak, ANTYK, Kęty.
Malebranche N. (2011), Poszukiwanie prawdy, tłum. M. Frankiewicz, Wydawnictwo IFiS PAN, Warszawa.
Nathan G. (1987), Comments on Tweyman and Davis, „Hume Studies” 13 (1): 98–103.
O’Connor D. (2001), Hume on Religion, Routledge, London/New York.
O’Connor D. (2003), Skepticism and Philo’s Atheistic Preferences, „Hume Studies” 29 (2): 267–282.
Pike N. (2005), Hume on Evil, [w:] God and the Problem of Evil, W.L. Rowe (red.), Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
Sieczkowski T. (2007), Qui pro quo Dialogów, czyli pytanie o status teologii naturalnej, „Nowa Krytyka” 20–21: 265–301.
Spryszak P. (2005), O „teizmie empirycznym w Dialogach o religii naturalnej Dawida Hume’a,„Studia z Historii Filozofii” 6 (2): 59–80.
Tweyman S. (1987), Hume’s Dialogues on Evil, „Hume Studies” 13 (1): 74–85.
Wadia P.S. (1987), Commentary on Professor Tweyman’s “Hume on Evil”, „Hume Studies” 13 (1): 104–112.
Yandell K.E. (1990), Hume’s “Inexplicable Mystery”. His Views on Religion, Temple University Press, Philadelphia.